If you're sorting out tire disposal in Riverhead, NY, the questions are where, how many and how much. Around Riverhead, North Sea Transfer Station and the other Suffolk County sites on our map are the public options, and tire shops are often the easiest route of all. On a run to Town of Islip - Multipurpose Recycling Facility, passenger tires, light-truck tires and tires still on rims are often priced differently, so count what you have before calling. Rims, tractor tires and oversized truck tires are separate questions at many North Sea-area sites. Tires from a Shelter Island Heights-area farm or business may fall under commercial rules rather than household limits.
Use these listings, from North Sea Transfer Station to Town of Islip - Multipurpose Recycling Facility, as a starting point; the operators have the final word.
Fast facts on tire disposal in Riverhead, NY
- Start here: North Sea Transfer Station.
- Second option: Town of Islip - Multipurpose Recycling Facility, also near Town of Islip - Multipurpose Recycling Facility.
- Source page: Facilities • North Sea Transfer Station (also handy from North Sea).
- Expect a per-tire charge at many Hampton Bays-area sites; we don't list a confirmed price.
- Ask the tire shop first: many shops near Shelter Island Heights take old tires when you buy new ones.
Nearby sites on our map
We ranked 2 sites by fit and distance from Riverhead. Everything else in Suffolk County is on the county page; the tire disposal guide explains the general rules.
North Sea Transfer Station
North Sea Transfer Station is a transfer station 13 miles from Riverhead (straight-line) near North Sea. Our record for North Sea Transfer Station has coordinates but no street address. Our North Sea Transfer Station listing has no hours, so verify them before the Hampton Bays-area trip. Phone: (631) 283-5210. Check whether North Sea Transfer Station takes tires on rims.
Town of Islip - Multipurpose Recycling Facility
Check Town of Islip - Multipurpose Recycling Facility, a landfill 24.8 straight-line miles out near Holbrook. Our record for Town of Islip - Multipurpose Recycling Facility has coordinates but no street address. Call Town of Islip - Multipurpose Recycling Facility for hours before leaving Shelter Island or the city center; our record doesn't list them. We can't confirm tire rules at Town of Islip - Multipurpose Recycling Facility, so call.
With North Sea Transfer Station as the nearest pick, the county as a whole has 7 transfer stations, 4 recycling centers, 1 battery drop-off, 1 electronics drop-off, 1 yard waste site, and 1 landfill on Dumpmapper, 15 in total.
Official Riverhead information
The official source we checked (October 2026) for North Sea Transfer Station is Facilities • North Sea Transfer Station. It had nothing quotable on old tires, so ask the transfer station 13 miles out directly.
Tire drop-off tips for Riverhead
Ask that transfer station, about 13 miles away whether tires on rims are accepted; some New York sites want them dismounted first. Drain any trapped water and leaves before stacking tires in the truck for the transfer station 13 miles out. Stack tires flat in a pickup bed; they're bulky but light enough for one person to unload at that transfer station, about 13 miles away.
Ask whether the transfer station 13 miles out takes tractor, semi or off-road tires; those are commonly refused or priced separately from Hampton Bays to the city. Never burn tires around the landfill 24.8 miles out; tire smoke is toxic and open burning of tires is widely banned.
Trip tips for Suffolk County
Have a driver's license or utility bill handy if the site limits use to Hampton Bays-area residents. Holiday weeks often shift schedules at that transfer station, about 13 miles away, so recheck hours near any holiday. Ask whether the transfer station 13 miles out uses a scale or a flat rate; it affects how you should plan the tire load. Bring a tarp and straps for the tire load, since an uncovered load can earn a ticket on the way to that transfer station, about 13 miles away.
Call checklist for Riverhead
Questions to put to Shelter Island-area staff:
- Does the transfer station 13 miles out take passenger tires from anywhere between North Sea and downtown households?
- How does that transfer station, about 13 miles away price truck tires versus car tires?
- Does the operator of that landfill, about 24.8 miles away take oversized tires at all?
Other options for Riverhead
- Swap at the shop: the easiest route for most Shelter Island-area drivers is leaving old tires at installation.
- Repurpose: some farms and gardeners between here and Shelter Island Heights use old tires, though rules on storing them vary.
- Collection events: the office that runs the transfer station 13 miles out or New York sometimes runs tire amnesty or collection days; check the official page.
FAQ: tire disposal in Riverhead
Where can I take old tires in the area Town of Islip - Multipurpose Recycling Facility serves?
Our top match near Hampton Bays is that transfer station, about 13 miles away; tire acceptance and fees should be confirmed by phone.
Does Town of Islip - Multipurpose Recycling Facility's operator charge for tire disposal?
It depends on the site and tire size; confirm the current charge with the transfer station 13 miles out staff before you go.
Do Hampton Bays-area tire dealers accept used tires?
Ask the shop; take-back with new tires is common around Riverhead.
Do I need to remove rims before dumping tires around North Sea Transfer Station?
Rules vary around the landfill 24.8 miles out; dismounting may lower the charge.
Is this North Sea-area information official?
Entries like that landfill, about 24.8 miles away may lag behind changes; check with the site directly.
The bottom line
One call to that transfer station, about 13 miles away and a look at Facilities • North Sea Transfer Station settle most Hampton Bays-area questions; our Suffolk County page covers the rest.