A stack of worn tires in a Findlay-area garage doesn't go out with the weekly trash, which is why tire disposal in Fostoria, OH takes a little planning. We list 2 nearby site(s) starting with WIN Waste Seneca County, plus what the North Baltimore-area page says and a few cheaper alternatives. Anywhere along the Findlay side, passenger tires, light-truck tires and tires still on rims are often priced differently, so count what you have before calling. Whether you have two tires or twenty matters, since Findlay-area sites often cap household quantities. Tires dumped along roads cost Findlay-area money to clean up, which is why the legal drop-off routes matter.
Before driving to WIN Waste Seneca County, double-check anything you read here; open data can lag.
Quick answer: tire disposal in Fostoria, OH
- Top match: WIN Waste Seneca County.
- Fallback: Sunny Farms Landfill, LLC.
- Rules and contacts: Landfill in Fostoria, OH, plus a call to Sunny Farms Landfill, LLC.
- Expect a per-tire charge at many North Baltimore-area sites; we don't list a confirmed price.
- Ask the tire shop first: many shops near West County Road 18 take old tires when you buy new ones.
Where to go around Fostoria
Our map shows 2 relevant sites for Fostoria, most useful first. See the Seneca County page for every listing and our tire disposal guide for background.
WIN Waste Seneca County
On our map, WIN Waste Seneca County shows as a landfill in town. The listing gives 12500 W County Hwy 18, Fostoria, OH 44830 as the address for this Fostoria trip. Hours for WIN Waste Seneca County are missing in our data, so check ahead of the tire load from Carey or the city center. Ask whether WIN Waste Seneca County accepts tires and at what rate.
Sunny Farms Landfill, LLC
We have Sunny Farms Landfill, LLC down as a landfill in the city and out toward Carey. Route a tire load to 12500 West County Road 18, OH 44830. Hours for Sunny Farms Landfill, LLC are missing in our data, so check ahead of the tire load from Carey or the city center. EPA landfill data lists Sunny Farms Landfill, LLC, but that dataset includes closed sites, so call first from anywhere between Carey and downtown.
Zooming out past Findlay to the whole county, we list 2 landfills.
Official Fostoria information
Our Carey-area details lean on Landfill in Fostoria, OH, read in October 2026. For old tires, the page stayed general, so call WIN Waste Seneca County before loading.
Tire drop-off tips for Fostoria
Ask WIN Waste Seneca County whether tires on rims are accepted; some Ohio sites want them dismounted first. Drain any trapped water and leaves before stacking tires in the truck for WIN Waste Seneca County. Large piles may need an appointment or commercial account at the landfill on W County Hwy 18; ask before bringing a trailer full.
Keep tires separate from household trash in the truck so the W County Hwy 18 landfill attendant can count them quickly. Ask whether the landfill on W County Hwy 18 takes tractor, semi or off-road tires; those are commonly refused or priced separately in North Baltimore and nearby.
Planning the trip from Fostoria
Bring a tarp and straps for the tire load, since an uncovered load can earn a ticket on the way to the W County Hwy 18 landfill. Expect to show ID at the landfill on W County Hwy 18 if it serves only local residents. A same-day check of the W County Hwy 18 landfill's status avoids a wasted trip from the West County Road 18 side of town. Weekday mornings tend to be the quietest time to unload at the landfill on W County Hwy 18, while Saturday lines can stretch. A sorted load gets through the W County Hwy 18 landfill faster than a mixed one.
Questions to ask before going
To avoid surprises at the gate, ask:
- Is the landfill on W County Hwy 18 the right Carey-area site for tires?
- How does the W County Hwy 18 landfill price truck tires versus car tires?
- Does the operator of Sunny Farms Landfill, LLC take oversized tires at all?
- Does Ohio run any tire amnesty events near Carey?
Beyond the drop-off: Fostoria options
- Repurpose: some farms and gardeners from Carey to the city use old tires, though rules on storing them vary.
- Collection events: the operator of Sunny Farms Landfill, LLC or Ohio sometimes runs tire amnesty or collection days; check the official page.
- Swap at the shop: the easiest route for most Carey-area drivers is leaving old tires at installation.
Fostoria tire disposal FAQ
Where can I take old tires in the city and out toward North Baltimore?
Start with the landfill on W County Hwy 18, and check the Carey-area page or call about tire rules before loading up.
Will North Baltimore-area curbside pickup take a tire?
Generally no. Tires are kept out of regular North Baltimore-area trash in most places, so use a permitted drop-off.
Do Carey-area tire dealers accept used tires?
Often yes with a purchase; some North Baltimore-area shops take them for a fee without one.
Can I bring tires on rims to WIN Waste Seneca County?
Rules vary in Carey and nearby; dismounting may lower the charge.
How current are the listings for WIN Waste Seneca County?
It's compiled from public records, so the W County Hwy 18 landfill gate staff are the final word.
The bottom line
Confirm with the landfill on W County Hwy 18, skim Landfill in Fostoria, OH, and browse the Seneca County sites before hauling old tires from the area around Sunny Farms Landfill, LLC.