Dumpmapper

Disposing of specific items · · 5 min read

Recycling Drop-Off in Erie County, NY

4 recycling drop-offs in Erie County, NY with accepted materials on file, plus the nearest site to each town.

Recycling drop-offs in Erie County are spread across Erie County, and our data shows 4 with recorded materials lists. They’re useful for cardboard after a move, scrap metal, batteries and more. Here’s what each site’s record says.

A word on sources: the sites here are pulled from public data that Dumpmapper compiles, including EPA and state records and OpenStreetMap. We don’t publish fees, and we don’t fill gaps with guesses. If a detail matters to your trip, the operator has the final word.

Drop-offs on file

Bucks 4 Bottles

You’ll find Bucks 4 Bottles in Buffalo; it’s on file as a bottle and can return center. For directions, the address we hold is 932 Hertel Avenue, Buffalo, NY 14216. There are no hours in our record for this one. The listing names cans and plastic among the accepted materials.

Bottle & Can Retrieval Center (Tonawanda)

Listed as a bottle and can return center, Bottle & Can Retrieval Center (Tonawanda) operates out of Tonawanda, about 8.7 miles north of Buffalo. Address: 123 Broad Street, Tonawanda, NY 14150. We don’t have a schedule on file here. Our data shows it taking cans, glass, and plastic.

Bottle & Can Retrival Center

Listed as a bottle and can return center, Bottle & Can Retrival Center operates out of Tonawanda (about 6.8 miles north of Buffalo). For directions, the address we hold is 1942 Colvin Boulevard, Tonawanda, NY 14150. No posted hours are in our listing for it. The listing names cans and plastic among the accepted materials.

Tin Can Alley

Tin Can Alley is a recycling center based in Tonawanda, about 7.8 miles north of Buffalo. Street address on record: 386 Hinds Street, Tonawanda, NY 14150. There are no hours in our record for this one. Accepted items in our record include cans, glass, and plastic. Recycling drop-offs tend to reject loads contaminated with trash, so sort before you go.

All of them at a glance:

SiteTownTypeHours on file
Bucks 4 BottlesBuffalobottle and can return centerNot on file
Bottle & Can Retrieval Center (Tonawanda)Tonawandabottle and can return centerNot on file
Bottle & Can Retrival CenterTonawandabottle and can return centerNot on file
Tin Can AlleyTonawandarecycling centerNot on file

Distance from Erie County’s larger towns

Population figures are 2024 Census estimates, and distances are straight-line miles from the center of each town to the nearest recycling drop-off in our data, which can sit across a county line. Road miles will run longer.

Town2024 estimateClosest siteMiles (straight line)
Buffalo276,617Bucks 4 Bottles (Buffalo)3.9
Lackawanna19,629Bucks 4 Bottles (Buffalo)9.2
Tonawanda14,984Bottle & Can Retrieval Center (Tonawanda) (Tonawanda)0.5
Kenmore14,936Bucks 4 Bottles (Buffalo)1.2
Depew14,910Bucks 4 Bottles (Buffalo)8.9
Lancaster10,094Bucks 4 Bottles (Buffalo)10.9

From Lancaster, the nearest option is about 11 miles off (Bucks 4 Bottles), the farthest of the towns shown.

The most commonly accepted materials

Counting the 4 drop-offs above, here is how many list each material in our records: plastic (4), cans (4), and glass (2). Items near the end of the list are accepted at fewer sites, so check before you go.

New York has kept TVs, computers and many other electronics out of household trash since 2015.

Items that need another stop

Bagged recyclables, greasy pizza boxes and trash mixed in are the usual problems. Paint, chemicals and propane belong at a hazardous waste site.

General drop-offs near Buffalo

Hauling household trash or furniture along with it? These general drop-offs are closest to Buffalo:

A few practical tips

  • Flatten boxes. Most drop-offs ask for cardboard to be broken down.
  • Separate by material. Drop-offs usually have bins for paper, metal, glass and plastic.
  • Describe the load when you call. Mattresses, tires and appliances frequently carry their own charges or drop zones.
  • Confirm they take walk-up customers. Not every disposal site is set up for private vehicles.
  • Empty and rinse. Clean containers are less likely to be rejected.

If a drop-off trip isn’t practical

Scrap yards may pay for metal. Donation stores take usable items. Curbside recycling handles most everyday materials if you have service.

Common questions

Where can I recycle in Erie County?

We list 4 drop-offs with recorded materials, including Bucks 4 Bottles, Bottle & Can Retrieval Center (Tonawanda), and Bottle & Can Retrival Center.

What can I bring?

Accepted materials on file across these sites include cans, plastic, and glass. Check each listing.

Do I need to sort?

Usually, yes. Drop-offs commonly have separate bins for each material.

Can I recycle electronics there?

New York has kept TVs, computers and many other electronics out of household trash since 2015. Some drop-offs accept electronics; check the listing.

Do scrap yards pay?

Many pay for metal by weight and type. Call for current prices.

Bottom line

Our data points to 4 recycling drop-offs in Erie County. Pick the closest one that accepts your load, and confirm hours and rules by phone. Every listing we hold for the county is on our Erie County map page, and the New York page covers the rest of the state. For town-level detail, see Where to Recycle in North Tonawanda, NY: Drop-Off Sites.

Hauling it yourself? If the load won’t fit in the truck bed, a 6×10 ft open-rail utility trailer or a 4×8 ft folding trailer (it folds upright to store in a garage) can cost less than a couple of hauler trips. Tie everything down with ratchet tie-down straps; many sites charge extra for loose or uncovered loads.

Guides and tools

As an Amazon Associate, Dumpmapper earns from qualifying purchases.

Related posts