Using a landfill in Henry County typically means a trip to Hayes Landfill, the municipal solid waste landfill we list in New Castle. Altogether our data shows one landfill in Henry County. We also map each big town to its nearest landfill, because for some residents the closest one sits in the next county.
A word on sources: the sites here are pulled from public data that Dumpmapper compiles, including EPA and state records and OpenStreetMap. We don’t publish fees, and we don’t fill gaps with guesses. If a detail matters to your trip, the operator has the final word.
Where the Henry County landfills are
Hayes Landfill
Listed as a municipal solid waste landfill, Hayes Landfill operates out of New Castle. It’s listed at 3450 S. Spiceland Road, New Castle, IN 47362. We don’t have a schedule on file here. Being a municipal solid waste landfill, it is permitted for everyday household garbage, which is why most self-haul trash loads end up at sites like this.
Closest landfill to each town in Henry County
Population figures are 2024 Census estimates, and distances are straight-line miles from the center of each town to the nearest landfill in our data, which can sit across a county line. Road miles will run longer.
| Town | 2024 estimate | Closest site | Miles (straight line) |
|---|---|---|---|
| New Castle | 17,382 | Hayes Landfill (New Castle) | 2.2 |
| Middletown | 2,270 | Hayes Landfill (New Castle) | 14.8 |
| Knightstown | 2,158 | Hayes Landfill (New Castle) | 10.4 |
Middletown has the longest haul on this list, about 15 miles to Hayes Landfill, so residents there may want to combine trips.
Other general drop-offs in Henry County
Our data has no transfer stations, drop-off centers or convenience centers in Henry County, only the landfill above. That makes the landfill the main public drop-off option for many residents, so it’s worth confirming its hours before every trip.
What to expect at the gate
Typically you stop at a scale, describe the load, and then follow signs or an attendant to the unloading area. Some sites send residents to a separate convenience area rather than the working face. When you leave, you may cross the scale again to settle up. Pricing isn’t in our records; the operator can tell you the current rate and minimum.
What to keep out of a landfill load
Landfill permits spell out what each site may bury, and a few items almost always get turned around: household hazardous waste such as paint thinner, pesticides and pool chemicals, propane cylinders, car batteries, and liquids. Tires and appliances that hold refrigerant (fridges, freezers, window AC units) are often accepted only for a per-item charge or sent to a separate area.
Nearby landfills outside Henry County
County borders don’t stop a trash load. These landfills sit outside Henry County but within about 22 miles of one of its larger towns:
- Caldwell LF in Morristown, Shelby County
- Randolph Farms Landfill in Modoc, Randolph County
Sites run by a different county or town may charge non-residents more or turn them away, so mention where you live when you call.
A few practical tips
- Snap a picture before you leave. It helps when you describe the load at the scale.
- Secure everything. Strap or net the load and add a tarp; many sites charge more for uncovered loads and highways ticket for spills.
- Confirm they take walk-up customers. Not every disposal site is set up for private vehicles.
- Bring proof of residency. County-run sites often check a driver’s license or utility bill.
- Arrive with time to spare. Gates often close before the posted end time to clear the site.
Other options in Henry County
Junk removal services cost more but handle the lifting and hauling. A neighborhood or church cleanup day sometimes includes a free dumpster or a hauler visit, which can cover a garage cleanout without a separate trip. Curbside bulk pickup is worth checking first. Many cities and haulers collect large items on a schedule or by request, sometimes for a fee.
Frequently asked questions
Where is the Henry County, IN landfill?
Our listings show Hayes Landfill in New Castle (3450 S. Spiceland Road, New Castle, IN 47362). Confirm public access before you go.
What are the Henry County landfill hours?
We don’t have hours on file for the landfills in this county, so call before you go.
How much does the landfill cost in Henry County?
We don’t publish fees because they change and aren’t in our data. Many sites charge by weight with a minimum for small loads; call the site or the county for current rates. Our post on what a dump trip costs explains how pricing usually works.
Can residents haul their own trash to the landfill?
Often, yes, but not always. Some landfills serve only commercial haulers, and some send residents to a separate drop-off area. Ask when you call.
What’s the closest landfill to New Castle?
In our data it’s Hayes Landfill, about 2.2 miles in a straight line from the center of New Castle.
What can’t go to a landfill?
Hazardous products, propane cylinders and liquids are commonly refused, and tires and refrigerant appliances often need special handling.
Summing up
Hayes Landfill is the most complete listing we hold in Henry County; check the others above if another site is nearer to you. Every listing we hold for the county is on our Henry County map page, and the Indiana page covers the rest of the state.
Hauling it yourself? If the load won’t fit in the truck bed, a 6×10 ft open-rail utility trailer or a 4×8 ft folding trailer (it folds upright to store in a garage) can cost less than a couple of hauler trips. Tie everything down with ratchet tie-down straps; many sites charge extra for loose or uncovered loads.
Guides and tools
Furniture disposal guide · Appliance disposal guide · Mattress disposal guide · Dump cost calculator · All material guides
As an Amazon Associate, Dumpmapper earns from qualifying purchases.